Website Credibility: What Buyers Check After the Proposal

The meeting went well. The proposal went out on Thursday, with the right people named and the right projects mentioned.

On Monday morning, the buyer opens your website to check what they heard.

What they find there either backs up the proposal or contradicts it.

In Summary

  • Buyers often go back to a supplier’s website after a meeting or proposal to check what they were told
  • When the proposal and the website disagree, buyers tend to doubt both
  • The usual gaps are in services, people, proof and tone
  • Before the next proposal goes out, read the last one next to your website

Why do buyers go back to your website after a proposal?

A proposal is written for one buyer. Your website was written for everyone. When a decision is close, buyers want to know which one is the real you.

Some come back to remind themselves of what was said, especially when weeks pass between the meeting and the decision. Others weren’t in the room and are seeing you for the first time online.

We looked at the research buyers do before a first call in When a Prospect Researches You Before the Call. This visit comes later, and the questions are sharper.

If someone on the buyer’s side looked you up tonight, would they find the firm your proposal describes?

Where do proposals and websites tend to disagree?

It often starts with the service. A proposal leads on the work the buyer needs, which can be newer or more specialised than what the website was built around. An engineering firm pitching for a maintenance contract can end up sending the buyer to a website full of new builds. We covered how that happens in Is Your Website Hiding Half Your Business?

Names are another gap. A professional services firm puts a partner’s name on the proposal, and the buyer can’t find that partner on the team page.

Proof gaps are easy to spot. The proposal mentions a similar project, and the website’s case studies cover different work or leave that project out. When Your Portfolio Undermines Your Capability goes into that in more detail.

The tone can drift too. A proposal might promise a structured, senior-led service while the website reads like a much smaller or more casual business. Neither is wrong on its own. Side by side, they look like two different firms.

Why does a small gap matter so much?

At proposal stage, the buyer is weighing up risk. A mismatch gives them something to worry about.

They rarely raise it with you. Few buyers will email to ask why the partner in the proposal isn’t on your website. They notice it, though, and it counts against you when they compare you with a firm whose story holds together.

Does your website back up your proposals?

We build websites that tell the same story as your best pitch, and we’re happy to take a look at yours.

Get in touch

What should a returning buyer find?

The same story they heard in the meeting, told in more depth.

Start with a proper page for the service you pitched, with more detail than the proposal had room for. Show the people the buyer will deal with and why each one is right for the job. Then make sure your most relevant projects sit where a buyer would look for them.

Could a buyer find the project you mentioned in the meeting without asking you for the link?

Where do you start?

Take the last few proposals you sent and open your website next to them. Go through each claim and look for the page that backs it up. Where there isn’t one, write it down.

Gaps that show up in every proposal come first, because they’ll keep showing up until they’re fixed.

Then add links to your next proposal. Point the buyer to the pages that support what you’re saying, so the second visit confirms the first.

If you’d like a second pair of eyes on how your proposals and your website compare, get in touch.

About Lemongrass Media

Lemongrass Media is a boutique website design agency with offices in Milton Keynes, St Albans and Bedford. We design bespoke corporate websites that look great, work hard and deliver real results for your business.

Contact us | View our corporate website portfolio | Corporate Website Design Services

Lemongrass Media Limited registered office address: 2 Manor Farm Court, Old Wolverton Road, Old Wolverton, Milton Keynes, MK12 5NN.
Registration in England & Wales. Registration number: 8596811 | Privacy Policy